Put-in-Bay Visitors & Convention Bureau - Company Logo

Golf Cart Rentals at Put-In-Bay →

Book Now!

Goat Soup And Whiskey

Goat Soup And Whiskey Particulars

Goat Soup And Whiskey is open from Mid May to the end of September. Daily hours of service run from 11:30 – 10 pm daily.  Located just a mile south of the downtown area on Catawba Avenue, just past the churches and before Heineman’s Winery and the Perry’s Cave & Family Fun Center. The first floor is home to the Put-in-Bay Chocolate Factory & Museum. a popular place for sweets and ice cream.

Goat Soup And Whiskey Where Fresh Is Defined!

The talented Goat Soup And Whiskey chefs have created a menu to please any palate. They take pride in every dish they serve, which shows in their creative presentations. The three on-site gardens provide many fresh vegetables and herbs in their dishes.

Other herbs, vegetables, and fruits in their entrees and cocktails are fresh from local markets and farms, such as Bergmans Orchards on the mainland. There is no substitute for the difference fresh ingredients make in their flavorful entrees.

Fresh does not end with their gardens! it extends to their seafood which features Lake Erie Yellow Perch and Walleye, two of the finest freshwater-eating fish on the planet! Caught fresh daily from Lake Erie, the Perch is the prime ingredient in their popular Perch Tacos, favored by locals and tourists alike.

Hand-fileted Perch is lightly dusted with breading and fried, then served in a warm tortilla with their secret “pali wali” sauce and cabbage mixture. The Walleye is expertly prepared in several styles depending on your preference.

Equally as popular are their delicious secret recipe homemade soups. They rotate their soups daily, using only the finest ingredients and slow-cooking methods. Be sure to ask your Goat Soup And Whiskey server about the soup specials served by the cup or bowl. Definitely worth checking out!

The Goat Soup And Whiskey Menu Highlights

• Perch Sandwich or Dinner
• Reuben Balls corned beef, sauerkraut, and swiss cheese, breaded and fried with a side of thousand island dressing
• Lollypop Style Lamp Chops (Goat Soup And Whiskey Specialty!)
•Seared Scallops
• Frieda’s Walleye a la Fran (walleye fillet crusted with parmesan breading and sautéed in garlic butter, capers, and lemon)
• Chicken Piccata
• Frog Legs with cajun lemon butter

A Blue Cheese sirloin cooked to medium rare, pan-seared scallops with Jasmine rice and the Duck Breast ala ponzu sauce are just a few of the other scrumptious dinner entrees. Perfect for date night or special occasions, The Goat Soup And Whisky is sure to become one of your favorite Put-in-Bay Restaurants.

Photo Of The Goat Soup And Whiskey One of our Put-in-Bay Bars And Pubs

The Goat Soup And Whiskey Features Specialty Cocktails, An Extensive Wine List & Craft Beers

We would be remiss if we did not mention their extensive and impressive wine list! Loaded with reds and whites from several countries across the world. The beer selection features a full range of domestic and imported selections that will pair well with your food selections.

Their cocktail creations are mind-boggling! A fun mix of fresh takes and classic favorites, feel free to be adventurous. The martini menu includes everything from a Cinnamon Toast Martini to a Peaches and Cream.

The fresh fruit cocktails are an ideal summer drink with locally sourced fruits. Try a Banana Bliss made with fresh bananas, Bacardi rum,  ice cream, and creme de cacao.

Goat Soup And Whisky also feature an outdoor Biergarten with its unique menu. You can dine al fresco on the front grounds and enjoy a selection of Bavarian-style food favorites. Bratwurst, Beer Cheese Soup, and a Bavarian Pretzel all pair very well with an ice-cold Steigl Beer. There is plenty of parking for Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rentals, the best way to travel to the Goat Soup Whiskey!

The Goat Soup Whiskey is located near all the popular Put-in-Bay Hotels and home rentals. After a fine dining experience, take time to enjoy a few of the area attractions. You are just a few minutes away from exciting locations such as the South Bass Island Lighthouse and the new Put-in-Bay Sign, where you can memorialize you and your group’s Put-in-Bay Ohio Vacation with a photo. The sign is located at South Bass Island State Park.

Helpful Links

WIN A FREE WEEKEND!

Be sure to enter to win one of all expenses paid weekend at Put-in-Bay! Just click the link below, complete the form and you are entered to win!
+

WINNERS PICKED MONTHLY

Winners will be notified by email monthly and receive two nights at a Put-in-Bay Resort Hotel, Overnight Golf Cart rentals & meals!
ENTER HERE

Island Events

Check our Calendar of Events & find out what's happening at Put-in-Bay! There is always a fun time, from our annual Piratefest weekend to our season-ending Halloween Bash!
+

Spending more than a day in Put-in-Bay?

Browse our exciting line up of this seasons events on our Put-in-Bay Event Schedule. There's almost always something special going on!
Click Here

Island Attractions

With over 30 unique Put-in-Bay Attractions there is something to interest everyone of all ages. From Caves to watersports, Put-in-Bay packs a punch when it comes to family fun!
+

Spending more than a day in Put-in-Bay?

No place in the MidWest offers as wide of a variety of fun-filled things to do as Put-in-Bay. From educational or action & adventure, our local attractions with ensure a memorable vacation!
Click Here

Golf Cart Rentals

Put-in-Bay Golf Carts are available seating 2-4-6 & 8 passengers! You can rent by the hour, daily & overnight! Be sure to reserve by the link below!
+

Spending more than a day in Put-in-Bay?

Put-in-Bay Golf Cart Rentals rent daily, overnight & multiple days. Gas Powered Golf Carts ensure uninterrupted driving! Book Your Cart Rental Today!
Click Here

(419) 285-4628

820 Catawba Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

WEBSITE

Andy M.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Highest Quality Restaurant on the Island- We just returned from a Put-in-Bay visit and were pleasantly surprised to try this quality gourmet restaurant for dinner. We each had one of the walleye meals and found them superb. We tried it based on other reviews and were satisfied. If you plan to eat at Goat Soup And Whiskey on the weekend, reservations are necessary. We had about a half-hour wait on a Tuesday without reservations. However, worth the wait! goat soup and whiskey menu was the bomb!

Matt W.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Surpassed our expectations-Our hotel recommended the Goat Soup And Whiskey as a quality dining experience. We were impressed with the environment, service, and food. Dining on the terrace was so relaxing with the cool, clear weather. And the food! I chose two appetizers and half a House Salad, and my friend had the ribeye steak served with seasonal vegetables. Fresh bread and dipping oil with balsamic were served as we lingered for our meals - very delicious. My half-salad was a plentiful serving of beautiful colorful mixed greens. The oysters Rockefeller were brought piping hot and absolutely delicious; the loaded mushroom caps (Italian sausage) baked with cheese and flavorful marinara were also burning out of the oven and delectable. The steak cooked perfectly, and the freshly cooked vegetable mix still had body and was not overcooked. We're already conversing about another island visit and plan to make this location a part of the adventure.

Steve A.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Get the soup!!! Amazing service and food. Goat Soup And Whiskey gluten-free selection could be better but overall, the meals and drinks are excellent. We sat on the patio, and that helped an awesome atmosphere. I had the lime and coconut drink, New England clam chowder, and the shrimp po boy. Great food!

Jamie S.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Excellent food, wonderful service at Goat Soup And Whiskey Creme Brûlée martini, mule, and creamsicle were made perfectly! Food was given hot and incredible flavor! We'd go back—excellent restaurant and service.

Blake S.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Open for Dinner! WE had a lovely feast here recently. We were elated to find them open on a weeknight during the week after Labor Day. The food and courtesy were superb. We had mussels, stew and salad, and dessert. The outdoor deck is beautiful but was unfortunately packed when we visited, so we ate inside, where the tables were sufficiently spaced. All in all good experience.

Tara D.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Best meal of our week at Put-in-Bay! We had finished our day trip to the island and chose to check out Goat Soup And Whiskey restaurant before grabbing the ferryboat back to the mainland nd were so delighted we did. It is in a shared structure with a beer garden and ice cream, chocolate, and candy store on the outskirts of town, away from the main roads. They had specified closing hours between lunch and dinner, but when requested, the kitchen decided to fill our order as we needed to catch the final ferry out and would not have been capable of doing so with a 5 pm start to dinner. I appreciated a Basil Mojita with blackberries added, that was awesome, and my husband liked his choice of beer. The roasted beet salad and lamb burger (topped with a fried egg) were both so good! This was far above the best food experience of our week-long trip to the area! Highly suggest it! Outside and indoor dining are available (dogs were allowed at the outdoor seating). Our server was great - just a well-rounded end to our visit to the island!

Kerry F.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
This must be on your checklist if you are seeking a fantastic dinner. Came to Goat Soup And Whiskey for dinner while on a weekend vacation. Our waitperson was terrific, her timing was well paced, and her recommendations were spot on also. Be sure to give the Ruben balls a try. The New England clam chowder was the finest I have ever eaten. The tuna was seared to ideal. I also appreciated a Westcoast cooler for a hot summer day. One of the best put in bay restaurants

Idalia G.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Delicious food and great ambiance-Had a lunch reservation here, and everything was unbelievable. The hostess, meals, waiters, and the establishment all were top-notch. The Goat Soup And Whiskey menu had some specials and specialty food, which was fantastic. My choice was the Walleye fries appetizer. They were so pleasing! The environment was laid back island time, which was so invigorating and calming. We had some beverages, good nourishment, and a good time.

Marcio S.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
A Real Gem: Based on recommendations from several locals, we had dinner at The Goat on our first evening in Put-In-Bay, then made reservations for the next evening while there. It was that good. I was searching for walleye and was satisfied. the goat menu was really good. They served it several ways, and all were scrumptious! My wife had a ribeye steak and then a filet on the second evening, enjoying both. We also loved the drinks - the best Mojito I ever had! The team is quite pleasant and observant. We will be back!

Portillo D.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
The service was excellent. Excellent place for dinner; both entrees and appetizers were fine. Had a fantastic Key Lime Martini! If you want to dine here, definitely make reservations. It's worth it.

John M.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
The best food on Put-in-Bay, hands down, is at the Goat Soup And Whiskey. The best espresso martini I've ever had in my whole life. The clam chowder was the finest I've ever had as well. A large variety of choices on the menu. Beautiful terrace area for outdoor dining. I make it a point to always visit here on the island. I can't wait to go back!

Marie R.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Fantastic food tonight at the Goat Soup And Whiskey. I enjoyed the escargot and got my group to try them after some explaining, and they were mouthwatering. I also had the chicken marsala and the Perch. Very pleased with the meals and service and will be happy to return.

Kendra J.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
The Goat Soup And Whiskey housed our entire bachelorette group, and we had excellent service and wonderful food! The tortilla soup was great, and my fish tacos were also delicious. We ordered tons of their appetizers to divide between the table, and everyone remarked on how amazing their fare was. We had about 20 individuals, and everyone walked away happy. The team is incredibly cordial and accommodating for our big party as well. goat soup and whiskey menu was super!