Put-in-Bay Visitors & Convention Bureau - Company Logo

Golf Cart Rentals at Put-In-Bay →

Book Now!

Frosty Bar Family Pizza

With a Put-in-Bay twist, Frosty Bar Family Pizza is a classic dive bar. It is the perfect place to celebrate summer on Put-in-Bay with extra delicious food served alongside live music, pool tables, and the game on TV.

In the evenings, the masses are entertained by a DJ or pair! To see who’s playing, be sure to review the Put-in-Bay Entertainment Schedule!

At the rear of the Frosty Bar Family Pizza bar, Big Man’s Burrito Stand is stationed and serves the best Mexican food on the island. Buriitos, Walking Tacos & More! With a serious side of taste, Frosty’s serves up traditional American fare.

Frosty Bar Family Pizza Menu Highlights

For breakfast, try:

Country Benedict
Sausage Gravy and Biscuits
Mexican Sunrise
Eggs Benedict

Frosty Bar Family Pizza Lunch & Dinner Menu

  • Frosty Bar Family Pizza Family Meal
  • Italian Sub
  • ANY of the Fabulous Pizzas
  • Chicken Cobb Salad
  • Tossed Salad

Some of the best Bloody Marys can be found at Frosty Pizza, topped off with a signature Frosty pickle. They make a wide variety of innovative cocktails for all hours of the day. Frosty Family Pizza is also a favorite place for those seeking to satisfy a late-night food craving!

Frostys Bar Family Pizza Speciality Cocktails

 

Frosty Mug Cocktails:

  • Bottled or Canned Beer
  • Draft Beer
  • Irish Iced Coffee
  • Cuban OJ
  • Frosty O
  • Formosa
  • Bloody Mary
  • Classic Margarita
  • Bottled Domestic or Canned Beers
  • Ice Cold Draft Beers
A Photo of Frosty Bar Family Pizza Put-in-Bay Bars And Pubs Option

Ideally located close to most Put-in-Bay Hotels,  Frosty Bar Family Pizza is an excellent first or last spot on the island. Swing by for a bite or drink before visiting one of the many Put-in-Bay attractions on the island.

Why not enjoy a little shopping after a hearty meal at Frosty Family Pizza Bar? Many nearby gift shops are here, only steps away! The Country House, Lovella Fashion Clothing, Put-in-Bay Surf Shop, and the Carriage House are located right on the Delaware Avenue strip! Then head to the famous Blue Marlin Pool Bar at the Put-in-Bay Resort for an afternoon of fun!

Helpful Links

Hotels & Resorts

Get the lowest rates on Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts by booking directly on the Put-in-Bay Resort website! Comfortable accommodations await, so book today, and enjoy your stay.
+

Spending more than a day in Put-in-Bay?

Book Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts by clicking below! Convenient online booking ensures the best rooms at the best rates. Experience Put-in-Bay in comfort!
Click Here

Island Events

Get the lowest rates on Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts by booking directly on the Put-in-Bay Resort website! Comfortable accommodations await, so book today, and enjoy your stay.
+

Spending more than a day in Put-in-Bay?

Book Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts by clicking below! Convenient online booking ensures the best rooms at the best rates. Experience Put-in-Bay in comfort!
Click Here

Island Attractions

Get the lowest rates on Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts by booking directly on the Put-in-Bay Resort website! Comfortable accommodations await, so book today, and enjoy your stay.
+

Spending more than a day in Put-in-Bay?

Book Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts by clicking below! Convenient online booking ensures the best rooms at the best rates. Experience Put-in-Bay in comfort!
Click Here

Golf Cart Rentals

Get the lowest rates on Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts by booking directly on the Put-in-Bay Resort website! Comfortable accommodations await, so book today, and enjoy your stay.
+

Spending more than a day in Put-in-Bay?

Book Put-in-Bay hotels and resorts by clicking below! Convenient online booking ensures the best rooms at the best rates. Experience Put-in-Bay in comfort!
Click Here

419-285-3278

252 Delaware Ave, Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

WEBSITE

Sylvia W.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Best Breakfast in town and welcoming to dogs and large parties My husband and I was looking for restaurants in Put in Bay that have a variety of choices for Breakfast and would also allow our dog to be with us. Frosty Bar Family Pizza welcomed our dog and had an assorted menu that permitted my husband to enjoy eggs, bacon, and potatoes while I had oatmeal, chia pudding, and fresh fruit. The coffee carafe was kept full.

I did try a portion of the Cinnamon French Toast, which I liked. Overall, a welcoming restaurant with an extensive breakfast menu that we couldn't find in the two other restaurants that serve Breakfast at Put-in-Bay. Best to come early, as it gets jam-packed and accommodates many big groups.

Brady H.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Frosty Bar Family Pizza had amazing live music and fine food. Everything is self-serve. No waitperson comes to you. We drove to hear live music by Rusty Bladen. The music was wonderful. One night we had good pizza, and the next night we had Mexican, which was great—an enjoyable place. frosty's pizza menu was pretty big!

Harold V.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Frosty Bar And Family Pizza had amazing live music and fine food. Everything is self-serve. No waitperson comes to you. We drove to hear live music by Rusty Bladen. The music was wonderful. One night we had good pizza, and the next night we had Mexican, which was great—an enjoyable place.

Tyler K.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Frosty Bar Family Pizza is Still the Heartbeat of Put-in-Bay! I could write pages of shining reviews, but I'll focus on Breakfast, which I feasted here five straight days in September. Numerous times on my travels, I've had to ask for extra cream & sweetener for my coffee or napkins at various diners, but never here. The napkin container & coffee reserves are on the table. You get an ice-cold bottle of water and a pot of coffee when you sit down.

If the sauce you desire is not on your table, there is a station a few steps away from it. I had at least six additional servers/bartenders besides the proprietors, and all were upbeat and courteous, many with positive stories about Put-in-Bay and their time working at Frosty Bar And Family Pizza, and they performed their job well, too. Granted, it was the off-season, but my orders and drinks were flawless and punctual. I hope to see you next trip! A Put-in-Bay visit is complete if you stop in at least once (make that once a day) at Frosty Pizza Bar!

Fabian K.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Great Breakfast And Brunch At Put-in-Bay! We reached Put in Bay around 9 am, and this was one of the only locations other than Pasquales down the way that was available, so we chose to stop in for Breakfast and coffee. We wanted something small, so we ordered breakfast sandwiches, which were the perfect size. Our waitress also provided us with hot coffee, which was perfect after coming off the ferry's top deck, and it was chilly outside. Frosty Bar Family Pizza Prices were a little up there, but it wasn't too bad. We thought we were done and tried to go somewhere else for drinks, but after finding nothing else was available, we decided to return for drinks, which were actually super good.

Beth Ann D.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
My boyfriend had the Bloody Mary, which was spicy, and I had the Island mimosa, made with pineapple juice instead of orange juice, and it was delicious! Our overall experience was outstanding and I would recommend the friendly atmosphere and great drinks at Frosty's! It was relatively quiet, so it was quiet, but the staff kept up with us and made sure we had everything we required. In addition to Breakfast, Frosty Bar A Family Pizza also have a pizza and sub place, a bar in the rear, and then a burrito stand, which was closed the day we were there.

Trey H.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
I love this bar! Frosty Bar And Family Pizza is one place we always have to hit when we're in Put in Bay Pizza mode! The backyard bar is fantastic and all the bartenders are very friendly. The pizza here is also wonderful, and the Breakfast is the best! Super fun place with a friendly atmosphere and great staff. Stop here for a beer in a frosty mug!

Bill V.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Short stay vacation We went to Frosty Bar And Family Pizza late on a Monday night, just for snacks and drinks, we got a pizza with meatballs and pepperoni, and I'm not sure what it was called but it was a great wide selection of beer and great drinks, good service, good price

Martin S.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
Cheap drinks, good food, fun environment. We had drinks and lunch on our first day. Drinks are cheap and good, which led us back on our last day. We had Breakfast and drinks again. This will be one of our go to's when we head back to Put-in-Bay. putinbay ohio frosty bar!

Amir F.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
This restaurant/bar was SPOTLESS! Beautiful hardwood floors and calm colors on the walls. And the service was very sharp. Jurgis even brought us a kid's fun paper so my grandson and I could play tic tac toe while cooling off. We didn't intend to come here, we were hot and exhausted, and this was the place before us. frosty's restaurant menu was reasonably priced. I suggest families to come here. We'll be back.

Teela H.

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
An OASIS on a SCORCHING HOT day!! My grandson and I were greeted at Frosty Bar Family Pizza by Jurgis with a frosty cold pitcher of water and 2 cups the moment we sat down. It was HELL outside, and we were exhausted from the heat. We ordered the Brie and chicken pizza with sundried tomatoes to nibble on while we cooled down and rested. Fabulous!!! We also ordered frozen drinks, one smoothie, and one very boozy drink for me, which were good. frostys bar & family pizza big man's burrito stand put-in-bay menu all were good!